Was the Shooting of Giffords a Hate Crime?

2 comments
Female Candidates, Media/Media Criticism, Sexism

Although Jared Lee Loughner’s attempted assassination of Gabrielle Giffords raised many questions about how the polarized political environment may have motivated this mentally disturbed young man, one aspect of the Tucson massacre that has received little attention is misogyny.

Loughner left behind several notes, including one that read “die bitch”–a gender slur that implies Giffords may have been targeted because she is a woman. Because gender slurs have become so acceptable in U.S. society, most people fail to recognize them as slurs at all. But imagine the headlines if Loughner had targeted a black member of Congress and left a note reading “die n****r,” or a gay member of Congress with the note “die f*g.” In those cases, the racist or homophobic aspect of the story would be mentioned in every article on the subject!

Other evidence, too, suggests that Loughner targeted Giffords because she was a woman. According to friends and acquaintances, he had become “contemptuous of women in positions of power” in recent years. Tellers at the local bank report that Loughner made openly sexist comments about how women should not be able to hold positions of authority, especially when they denied one of his requests. Some tellers would position a finger on the alarm button whenever he approached. And while Loughner exhibited disruptive behaviors in many of his community college classes, his level of hostility toward one female professor over a grade was such that she felt physically threatened and requested campus safety be present during class.

Loughner had previously met Giffords in 2007 at a “Congress on Your Corner” event. He asked her, “How do you know words mean anything?” and Giffords, assuming Loughner was referring to bilingual issues, responded with a few phrases in Spanish. The young man was angered by her response and reportedly told a friend that Giffords was “stupid and unintelligent.”

So it is not unreasonable to assume that Loughner targeted Giffords because she is a woman in a position of power. If so, his crime falls under federal hate crime legislation, which regulates crimes that target members of protected classes (i.e., race, religion, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity and disability). Officials at the Justice Department could inspire a national dialogue about crimes motivated by the hatred of women if they choose to enforce this law in the Giffords case.

The fact that few media reports note the obvious misogyny at play in this case is a testament to the fact that sexism is so ingrained in U.S. culture that it’s not even worth mentioning.

Note: This post was originally published at Ms. Blog on January 19, 2011

http://msmagazine.com/blog/blog/2011/01/19/was-the-shooting-of-giffords-a-hate-crime/

2 thoughts on “Was the Shooting of Giffords a Hate Crime?”

  1. Christopher Lee Kuaiwa says:

    It’s true and unfortunate that gender slurs have become so acceptable in U.S. society. In my opinion, entertainment plays the largest role in the spread of deviant behavior.

    Swim4living

  2. Pistol Lohan says:

    i agree that he targeted her because she was a woman, but i still lump this motivation in with the political one, because they go hand-in-hand in terms of the negative influence media (cable news in particular) can have on such an emotionally disturbed person. he didn’t shoot her because of deep, well thought out political or misogynistic reasons, but because they were planted in his head by the main stream media (for lack of a better term). you touched on this quite accurately in your blog post about gender slurs, but there is a common ground between your posts that hasn’t really been explored. something like the “right wing slut” comment plants two very negative ideas in the viewer’s mind and gives them dual motivation to hate somebody.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s